‘A mistake is a mistake’: top Hong Kong gynaecologist admits wrongly removing ovaries
Verified: 2 outlets in 2 countries have reported this story since Nov 17, 1 of them from Hong Kong.
A veteran Hong Kong professor in obstetrics and gynaecology has confirmed that he is the surgeon who wrongly removed a woman’s ovaries during an operation at a private hospital, the South China Morning Post has learned. Professor Cheung Tak-hong, a consultant at the Chinese University of Hong Kong (CUHK) Medical Centre, admitted to the SCMP on Wednesday that he was the doctor who removed the 45-year-old woman’s ovaries in an operation to take out her uterus and fallopian tubes. “The operation...
How sure are we
Two or more outlets reported this story and its reliability score reached 65%, so WorldPulse marks it verified. That means more than one outlet says so, not that it is proven true.
Who reported it
1 outlet from Hong Kong, where the story is: South China Morning Post · how we count
- Nov 17, 11:54 AM UTCFirst reportHong Kong hospital blames surgeon’s ‘cognitive lapse’ for wrong removal of ovariesscmp.com ↗
- Nov 18, 2:39 AM UTC+15 hSurgeon had ‘cognitive lapse’ when mistakenly removing woman’s ovaries, Hong Kong hospital sayschannelnewsasia.com ↗
- Verified: a second independent outlet reported itNov 18, 2:39 AM UTC · +15 h
- Nov 18, 11:16 AM UTC+23 h· you’re reading this‘A mistake is a mistake’: top Hong Kong gynaecologist admits wrongly removing ovariesscmp.com (again) ↗
[Claude] Report 2 covers the same wrongly removed ovaries surgery at a Hong Kong private hospital, adding the hospital's explanation of a cognitive lapse, and does not conflict with Report 1.
4h agoScore bands
What moves the score
Not in the score: AI checks and reader flags. Verified is separate: two or more independent outlets and a score of at least 65%.
Very high · How we score this